The NYT has a loving and heart-warming replica of Watson’s letter describing the discovery of DNA to his 12 year old son in 1953. To say something nice about it, it’s amazing to see what a good teacher Watson was – he describes the double-helix, first-time out, from a standing start, better than it is usually described by professional educators in high school and college. What’s even more amazing and heart-warming is that Watson completely forgets to mention Rosalind Franklin to his son. You know, Rosalind Franklin…the Jewish woman chemist who took the x-ray diffraction picture of DNA that led directly to Watson’s theory? Never heard of her? Riiiiiiiiiight.
April 11, 2013
The Pentagon-Neuroscience Connection Part 2
As I brought up last week, we should watch the merging of DOD and NIH monies in the pursuit of neuroscience research. Here’s an article on one use the Pentagon may want to put all this research to: “Pentagon to build robots with real brains.” As a side note, this seems far-fetched.
April 3, 2013
Eisenhower’s Ghost and Obama’s Brain
DARPA’s got skin in this game for a reason. Visions of neuroweaponry are dancing through at least some of their heads. It’s time to ask some questions. America’s just flubbed two wars, at incredible expense, in which overconfidence in DARPA weaponry played a huge role. Let’s find out exactly what their thinking about the BRAIN initiative is, and how this military-scientific collaboration is supposed to play out. And let’s hope that we don’t have a new challenge on our hands – to keep not only weapons out of the wrong hands, but the wrong heads.
April 2, 2013
The NYT Comes Around
Yesterday I posted that the White House’s upcoming BRAIN initiative was conceptually incoherent, and I snarkily implied the NYT needed some science-fiction checkers for its overly credulous reporting of what we could expect out of the initiative.
What a difference a day makes! In an article today they write: “the new initiative… has, as yet, no clearly defined goals or endpoint. Coming up with those goals will be up to the scientists involved and may take more than year.”
April 1, 2013
The antidote to ADHD isn’t Ritalin, it’s play: let’s make recess the first class of the day!
For anyone reading today’s NYT article on the ADHD “epidemic” (sidenote: the only epidemic is in the eyes of the diagnosticians and, worse, the school administrators who ensure that normal boys look hyperactive by sticking them in classrooms at 8am every morning), it wasn’t hard to notice someone conspicuously absent: Jaak Panksepp. If you haven’t read Panksepp’s most recent article on the normal evolutionary function of attentional shifting, and on the necessity of reorganizing our grade schools to make recess the first class of the day, read it now (link here…)
April 1, 2013
Only Connectome
As a rather precise analogy, knowing the distribution of cell phones in the United States might tell you this much (pinchy fingers) about what Americans are saying to one another. A complete list of every phone’s contact history (eg, who is calling who, and when, and for how long) would tell you this much (hands a foot apart) about what Americans are saying. But actually recording all of the conversations would tell you this much (arms stretched as wide as possible) about what Americans are saying.
March 31, 2013
Moment of Neural Zen
Everything you ever wanted from a nervous system and more. Perception, analysis, intentionality, persistence, problem solving, and motor behavior up the wazoo.
March 31, 2013
Yes Albert, there is spooky action at a distance
Einstein famously hated this idea, wanting all cause-effect relationships to be “local” (meaning limited in speed to c). He petulantly referred to it as spooky action at a distance. Bell’s theorem gave it credibility, and now a series of experiments are proving it empirically.
March 30, 2013
Do axons think?
Time was when the cell body was the telephone mouthpiece and the axon was the telephone cord. Axons just passively conducted the information fed into them like so many cables. But this new article Neurosci. Res. 2013 Sasaki sets forward a summary of recent evidence that astrocytes camped out along the axon modify the signals that cell […]
March 30, 2013
The Known Universe
A nice 6-minute film in which the viewer looks back, from a rocketship, as she moves from the surface of the planet through the universe. Various scientific landmarks and facts are displayed over the course of the trip. Good for kids and context.
March 29, 2013
Impossible People
The phrase “impossible person” was coined by James Joyce. In this post I will define the term (or at least begin to) and in the posts that follow in this section I will try to shed light on the inner logic of impossible people, and on some of the techniques that can be used to make them possible.
March 29, 2013
The Medicalization of Deviance: Can Brain Images Detect Pre-Crime?
Many prisons in America are privately run, and wardens, making $40,000/year per inmate, have reasons to keep people in – the inmates are in a sense (unwilling) customers. So when they write that “this pattern of results raises the possibility that brain activity in regions such as the ACC, elicited by a simple experimental task, may lend incremental utility to existing behavioral risk factors in the ability to predict rearrest,” one worries about how, exactly, this information might be used.
March 28, 2013
More evidence of the concept of the self in non-humans
It has long been speculated that only animals capable of conceptualizing conspecifics as selves – unique individuals – who can transition from life to death would be capable of mourning.
March 28, 2013
Bees Detect Information from Electric Fields
Consistent with the observation that electric fields have three-dimensional configurations that can be identified by their shape, bees detect the fields formed on other bees’ exoskeletons.
November 3, 2012
What’s the Difference Between Psychology and Psychopharmacology?
A joke! It’s only a joke! A totally accurate joke.
November 2, 2012
What’s the Difference Between Mathematics and The Humanities?
I can’t imagine the square root of number one.
October 31, 2012
Zombies, Slavery, and The French: On the Extreme Peril of Bad Metaphysics
It is not enough to have expelled the barbarians who have bloodied our land for two centuries; it is not enough to have restrained those ever-evolving factions that one after another mocked the specter of liberty that France dangled before you. We must, with one last act of national authority, forever assure the empire of liberty in the country of our birth; we must take any hope of re-enslaving us away from the inhuman government that for so long kept us in the most humiliating torpor. In the end we must live independent or die.
October 30, 2012
What’s the Difference Between The Sciences and The Humanities? #2
Another metaphysical joke
October 30, 2012
Einstein’s Mentos + Diet Coke Experiment
If you’ve never seen someone drop 4 Mentos into a 2-liter bottle of Diet Coke (let alone done it yourself) you’re in for a treat. And if you’ve never dropped the speed of light into an inertial frame of reference before you’re in for an even bigger one. Because the Mentos/Diet Coke thing will blow your mind […]
October 29, 2012
What’s the Difference Between Physics and the Humanities?
A joke
October 29, 2012
Auguste Comte: A General View of Positivism (1856)
“The law is this: that each of our leading conceptions, each branch of our knowledge, passes successively through three different theoretical conditions: the Theological, or fictitious; the Metaphysical, or abstract; and the Scientific, or positive….the phenomena of human life… are yet equally subject to invariable laws; laws which form the principal objects of Positive speculation… [Positivism] rests at every point upon the unchangeable Order of the world. The right understanding of this order is the principal subject of our thoughts; its preponderating influence determines the general course of our feelings; its gradual improvement is the constant object of our actions.”
October 24, 2012
A Monkey Theory of Fairness
This brief video, especially at 0:45, shows a monkey making a fairness calculation. It is universally recognizable, and I won’t ruin it by discussing it.
October 22, 2012
Neuroself Live Blogs the Third Presidential Debate
9:41 – Obama is looking at Bob S. cracking up at Romney’s bad math like the geek in the front row of math class laughing at the quarterback who thinks the x axis is vertical.
October 22, 2012
Leonard Susskind on Fields, Particles, Mass and the Higgs Boson
Great video – 1.5 hours. High points: 34:46 A dipole in an electric field has more energy if it is oriented pointed upstream than pointed downstream. Because it is a dipole it is not moved by the field. But it has more mass (via E=mc2) 35:35-36:50 The Higgs field is not like molasses (as the […]
October 19, 2012
Think Like A Shrink #1: Don’t Psychoanalyze Your Family and Friends!
Out of 100 minutes of psychotherapy, a patient can expect at most 1-5 minutes to involve interpretations of what was “really” going on. It seldom seems that way because interpretation is what a patient remembers. But a seasoned shrink has learned that patients drop out of treatment if you bombard them with unwanted ideas about themselves. And that defeats the point of treatment. 1-5% of the time is plenty.
October 18, 2012
Think Like A Shrink: Proof
So here we go, on what will probably a long, drawn out excursion: the tools of my trade. If I were a dentist, what I’d be describing would be my picks and drills. If I were a basketball player these would be my moves. If I were a photographer these would be my camera settings and lenses. In psychiatry they just happen to be words. Which just happen to be the easiest kind of thing to distribute across the internet. Enjoy!
October 14, 2012
Neuroself Live Blogs the Second Presidential Debate
10:21 – I still think the story of this debate is that Romney has a huge wellspring of arrogant aggression at his disposal, and seems unable to modulate it sufficiently to appear Presidential. Obama comes close to naming it and challenging it, but pulls up short each time. Candy Crowley fails to discuss or contain it. And none of the audience members pulls an audible and ask Romney why he’s so angry.
October 14, 2012
Bento Spinoza: The Ethics (1677)
As, then, nature abhors a vaccuum (of which anon), but all parts are bound to come together to prevent it, it follows from this that the parts cannot really be distinguished, and that extended substance in so far as it is substance cannot be divided.
October 13, 2012
Popper’s Flawed Critique of Panpsychism
I suppose Popper has done us a favor here: he has combined bad thinking about memory, emergence, and materialism with sweeping arrogance. It’s a kind of apotheosis of bad anti-psychism, and should lead any curious person to wonder whether something isn’t terribly amiss (and insecure!) in modern materialism.
October 11, 2012
Neuroself Live Blogs the Vice Presidential Debate
10:18 Let me follow Ryan’s pro-life reasoning here.
1. My firstborn child looked like a bean on ultrasound in the womb.
2. After my firstborn child was born, we nicknamed them “bean”
3. Beans are human beings
4. Therefore I am against abortion.
10:19 Question: can somebody get a photograph of Paul Ryan eating beans? And then arrest him for murder?
October 11, 2012
Descartes, Revisted: Cogitans, Extended
The huge mistake Descartes made – and for which we are all still paying – is to conflate mass with extension. We know today that mass is not extension – we think of mass and extension as two different things, and that matter has both properties. They overlap so seamlessly – everything with mass has extension, and the only things we really can sense has mass – that we can forgive Descartes for missing that there are things in this world that have extension but not mass.
October 9, 2012
Renee Descartes: Not a Bad Philosopher. A Bad Physicist.
It is fashionable these days to “not believe in dualism,” though typically, if the conversation deepens, what is believed in its place turns out to be vague. Ask someone to explain – precisely – what they believe instead of dualism, and they often end up sounding like Obama in his first debate with Romney. There’s a […]
October 9, 2012
Renee Descartes: The World, or, A Treatise on Light (1629-33)
Note: reprinted without permission (but in fear of it disappearing) from here. Please read it there. Happy to take this down if the owner prefers. Short discussion on Wikipedia here. My comments on this here. In proposing to treat here of light, the first thing I want to make clear to you is that there can be […]
October 8, 2012
Frege (1956) The Thought: A Logical Inquiry
Does everything need a bearer without which it could have no stabilitv? I have considered myself as the bearer of my ideas, but am I not an idea myself? It seems to me as if I were lying in a deck-chair, as if I could see the toes of a pair of waxed boots, the front part of a pair of trousers, a waistcoat, buttons, part of a jacket, in particular sleeves, two hands, the hair of a beard, the blurred outline of a nose. Am I myself this entire association of visual impressions, this total idea? It also seems to me as if I see a chair over there. It is an idea. I am not actually much different from this myself, for am I not myself just an association of sense-impressions,an idea? But where then is the bearer of these ideas? How do I come to single out one of these ideas and set it up as the bearer of the rest? Why must it be the idea which I choose to call ” I “?
October 7, 2012
Borderline Personality Disorder on Monday Night Football
It’s football day again, and so it brings to mind that last Monday night I was watching the Bears destroy the Cowboys (until Kyle Orton came in!) and was surprised to hear, after Brandon Marshall caught a TD, one of the color on-field commentators mention in a matter of fact way that he had Borderline Personality Disorder
October 6, 2012
Reading List: The Self and the Neuroself
This reading list is a work in progress. If you buy the books from Amazon they give me 4% of their profit; I don’t want the money for myself but will donate it the South Yuba River Citizens League (Jeff Bezos is a billionaire; I might as well redistribute when I can; the Yuba is an actual river); avoid Amazon if you can and support your local independent bookseller!
October 6, 2012
The Electric Field is Real: Steven Weinberg
Thus, the inhabitants of the universe were conceived to be a set of fields, an electron field, a proton field, an electromagnetic field, and particles were reduced in status to mere epiphenomena. In its essentials, this point of view has survived to the present day, and forms the central dogma of quantum field theory: the essential reality is a set of fields, subject to the rules of special relativity and quantum mechanics; all else is derived as a consequence of the quantum dynamics of these fields.
October 5, 2012
Wittgenstein’s Panpsychism
Like many after him, and like Buddha before him, Wittgenstein believed – or at least his early version believed – in thoughts without a thinker. His logic went something like this: 1. Thoughts are facts of the world. 2. Facts are basic features of the world and do not depend upon other facts for their […]
October 4, 2012
What Was Romney Doing? He Was Winning!
The screenshot above is of an aggressive, slightly impulsive male primate named Chris Matthews describing the neuroselves of Mitt Romney and Barack Obama. Like me (check out the transcript of my live blog here) Matthews was watching the nonverbals during last night’s debate, and like me Matthews noticed that Romney’s were dominant and Obama’s submissive.Unlike me, his head exploded.
But if you think about it, the dynamic didn’t begin with nonverbals. It began with the verbals and then infected the nonverbals. If you think back to the (very weird) start of the debate, Obama led with a staggeringly submissive idea.
October 3, 2012
Neuroself Live Blogs the Presidential Debate
9:22 Romney head up, Obama head down. Romney smiling, Obama grimacing. Romney looking down, Obama looking up. These nonverbals are coursing into the central nervous systems of viewers across the country and communicating that Romney is winning.
October 3, 2012
Journalwatch: Dynorphin in Addiction
The dynorphin story – that it turns on the kappa opioid receptor, which more or less turns off the mu opioid receptor, which, being where heroin et al dock, prevents drug addiction – continues to impress. Boys, this one’s got legs!
October 2, 2012
Articles of Faith for a Church of the Second Law
1. We believe in the scientific method.
2. We believe the scientific method cannot produce every idea the mind can think, including – notably – many of the conjectures that are the basis for scientific experiments.
3. We believe that claims the mind cannot evaluate using the scientific method should be called metaphysical claims.
October 2, 2012
Journalwatch: Exercise Reduces Anxiety Through Galaninergic Dampening of the Locus Coeruleus
Running amplifies galanin expression in noradrenergic locus coeruleus (LC) and suppresses stress-induced activity of the LC and norepinephrine output in LC-target regions. Thus, enhanced galanin-mediated suppression of brain norepinephrine in runners is supported by current literature as a mechanism that may contribute to the stress-protective effects of exercise.
September 30, 2012
Bob Dylan was a Neuroscientist?
Shouldn’t science writers be expected to copy mainstream scientists, and present extensive citations and explanations of their conclusions? Before the internet, when all information was printed, the publishing industry dropped the practice of footnoting popular science in order to save paper and keep down costs. That’s not an issue now. All major publications should from hereon out have a “sources” or “supplementary materials” page – just as the major science journals, like Nature, do – on which reporters give background material. Holding them to this standard will ensure that they spell out, to themselves, their inner logic.
January 27, 2012
Anyone Know the Coordinates on This Thing?
Man shoots nail into head without consequence. Hilarity ensues.
January 26, 2012
Freud’s Baaaaaaaack: Depression’s Link to Insecure Maternal Attachment
“Freud comes in to this,” said co-author and psychiatrist Dr. Igor Galynker of Beth Israel Medical Center. “He blamed everything on the mother and it turns out the mother is absolutely the strongest gauge of depression you have.”
January 26, 2012
Nancy Kanwisher Interview on BBC
Nice BBC interview with Nancy Kanwisher that frames the modularity-model of the brain versus the RAM model of the brain. Of course, the more modules there are, the more selves there are, in a certain sense, and the more pressure there is on us to figure out what it is, exactly, that we’ve been meaning all these years by “self.”




April 14, 2013
3 Comments